How Faith Can Affect Therapy - NYTimes.com

Can belief in God predict how someone responds to mental health treatment? A recent study suggests it might.

Researchers at McLean Hospital in Belmont, Mass., enrolled 159 men and women in a cognitive behavioral therapy program that involved, on average, 10 daylong sessions of group therapy, individual counseling and, in some cases, medications. About 60 percent of the participants were being treated for depression, while others had bipolar disorder, anxiety or other diagnoses.

All were asked to rate their spirituality by answering a single question: “To what extent do you believe in God?”

The results, published in The Journal of Affective Disorders, revealed that about 80 percent of participants reported some belief in God. Strength of belief was unrelated to the severity of initial symptoms. Over all, those who rated their spiritual belief as most important to them appeared to be less depressed after treatment than those with little or no belief. They also appeared less likely to engage in self-harming behaviors.

“Patients who had higher levels of belief in God demonstrated more effects of treatment,” said the study’s lead author, David H. Rosmarin, a psychologist at McLean Hospital and director of the Center for Anxiety in New York. “They seemed to get more bang for their buck, so to speak.”

One possible reason for this, he said, is that “patients who had more faith in God also had more faith in treatment. They were more likely to believe that the treatment would help them, and they were more likely to see it as credible and real.”

As I read through this article a few thoughts came to mind,,,

1] Why are they equating spirituality with belief in God,,,spirituality is more than that.
2] No distinction appears to have been made between what denominational influence the participants were, the more "progressive" a "church" the more accepting of intervention. In other words believing a mental health issue is actually and illness and not a religious problem (not being right with God, lack of prayer) will reduce the self-loathing an individual may feel.
3] Spirituality or religion, higher power or God, terminology keeps changing.
4} Belief in God changes the focus to something external and outside of self that controls outcome. IF "therapy" doesn't work, God must have wanted it a such and vice versa. There is a presupposition of "magical" thinking.
5] One point I think they missed, is whether patients who attend church are more likely to develop mental illness in the first place. Religious ideation factors into the psychotic features of some illnesses.
6] One could believe in almost anything strongly enough and, after the fact, associate the result with "faith".
7] They do not define "faith" or "God" for that matter


How Faith Can Affect Therapy - NYTimes.com