Saturday, November 1, 2014

ADDENDUM::What David Gushee’s change of heart really means | Denny Burk

So the other day I posted about David Gushee's defection in regards to the acceptance of LGBT individuals and Jonathan Merrit's reaction. There was one specific point that Merrit made that I keyed in on, that I also feel is important.
"While other pro-LGBT Christian activists — including Justin Lee of the Gay Christian Network and Matthew Vines, author of “God and the Gay Christian” — have been dismissed in some circles as wet-behind-the-ears youngsters without formal theological training, Gushee, 52, is a scholar with impeccable credentials. He can add intellectual heft to what has largely been a youth-led movement, and is not someone who can be easily dismissed."
But as I stated in the previous posting, not everyone agrees with the above characterization of Gushee's news. One such person is Denny Burk who writes:
This is actually backwards. Pro-gay revisionist readings of scripture have been around for decades, and they were pioneered by “Christian” scholars. Evangelical scholars have decisively answered those revisions going back at least three decades. The conversation among religious scholars has gone under the radar of the larger public, but it has been there. And all of those old arguments are now showing up in the work of popularizers like Matthew Vines and Justin Lee. This has not been a “youth-led” movement. It’s been a “youth-led” warming-over of discredited heresies. Gushee doesn’t add any scholarly gravitas. We’ve had scholars advocating this heresy for decades.

I get the feeling that Jonathan Merritt regards Gushee’s defection as some kind of bellwether for evangelical views on sexuality. If that is what he intends, I think he is mistaken. Gushee is not the future of evangelicalism. He is the future of ex-evangelicalism. He joins a chorus of others who have left the faith once for all delivered to the saints (Jude 3) and who no longer represent what evangelical Christianity is all about. Anyone who looks to figures like Gushee to understand evangelical piety and faith will be inevitably misled.
"Discredited heresies" and "ex-evangelicalism" interesting choice of words don't ya think?

What David Gushee’s change of heart really means | Denny Burk

No comments:

Post a Comment